| Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 | |
|
|
Auteur | Message |
---|
Romantic Technofreak Engagé
Nombre de messages : 2 Date d'inscription : 27/02/2005
| Sujet: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 27 Fév 2005 - 12:45 | |
| Hello, I would like to accept the invitation Vespasiano made on tgplanes.com. I am German, I don´t speak French, although I understand some expressions because I had Latin in school. I am a WWII-aircraft-addict, including a strong sympathy for French aircraft, since I went through aviafrance.com and ailes-royales (this site about the French Naval Air Force sorrily doesn´t exist any more). On tgplanes.com, I use to create "duel" topics for to discuss about two comparable aircraft. Often, the response is good, but sometimes I am not satisfied. So let me continue here the duel between Marcel Bloch MB 152: and Curtiss P-36: I hope you are interested and may say something to this "inner-French" duel. As I can´t see how to post a link here, let me quote some opinions mentioned on tgplanes com: MarkJ: - Citation :
- Both planes were very close. The MB 152 had the edge in speed and armament, was a fraction lighter but didn't have the endurance of the Hawk 75. Unlike the Hawk, the MB 152 was later developed ( under the vichy govt' ) into a speedy fighter that would eventually top 400mph but wasn't put into production, Curtiss opting for the move to the Allison and the P-40.
The RAF tried a comparison with the Hawk 75 and a Mk 1 Spitfire and found the Hawk almost equal apart from speed. I would like to read reports on the MB 152's flying ability.
Corsarius: - Citation :
- The MB152 had stability problems, and drum-fed magazines. Both in the negative against the curtiss product.
I hope you enjoy this! Regards, RT | |
|
| |
Niko Adjudant-chef
Nombre de messages : 431 Localisation : La ville du pastaga eh con! Massilia! Date d'inscription : 06/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 27 Fév 2005 - 16:51 | |
| Thx a lot, but I know more things about german's planes than french's planes... I only know that le MB152 had very good armament thanks to his 2hispano 20mm mounted in the wings. And that both planes were very strong, hum could fly with a lot of hits. :? | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 27 Fév 2005 - 17:12 | |
| Hello Technofreak! welcome Thank you for this duel, this is very interesting... if you want we can create an english part on this forum, it could be easier for you... | |
|
| |
Adrian Von Berg Aspirant
Nombre de messages : 1968 Localisation : Paris-Est Date d'inscription : 05/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 27 Fév 2005 - 18:58 | |
| Hallo Technofreak !! Wilkommen...
Ich bin wie Niklaus, ich kenne ganz besser die Deutsche Flugzeuge als die Französiche... | |
|
| |
Romantic Technofreak Engagé
Nombre de messages : 2 Date d'inscription : 27/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Lun 28 Fév 2005 - 23:12 | |
| Thank you for your answers, friends! A special English forum for me isn´t necessary. I was just hoping for some "experts" about French aircraft, I would have a lot of questions as time goes on... hello | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Mer 2 Mar 2005 - 19:54 | |
| En fait Adrian, tu disais quoi en Allemand? Je parles assez bien Anglais et Espagnol, mais là... angry | |
|
| |
Niko Adjudant-chef
Nombre de messages : 431 Localisation : La ville du pastaga eh con! Massilia! Date d'inscription : 06/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Sam 5 Mar 2005 - 23:12 | |
| Ben je parles pas allemand, mais il a dit: Je suis comme Niklaus, je connais mieux les avions allemands que les Francais. | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Sam 5 Mar 2005 - 23:15 | |
| | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 6 Mar 2005 - 19:55 | |
| c'est intelligent, on se retrouve avec un allemand qui préfère les avions français, et des français qui préfèrent les avions allemands... angry | |
|
| |
Madalex Major
Nombre de messages : 888 Age : 37 Localisation : je vous ai dans le colimateur!! mouahahahahah! (Besançon) Date d'inscription : 05/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Lun 7 Mar 2005 - 21:51 | |
| | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Lun 7 Mar 2005 - 23:02 | |
| ...comme quoi l'aviation est vraiment une passion internationale! :D | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 13 Mar 2005 - 13:39 | |
| We have made a small file about the Marcel-Bloch MB-152 : http://forum.aviation-ancienne.fr/viewtopic.forum?t=110&start=45 | |
|
| |
Alban Capitaine de frégate
Nombre de messages : 7088 Age : 35 Localisation : Toulon (83) Date d'inscription : 04/02/2005
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 13 Mar 2005 - 13:40 | |
| Trop tard, il est passé sans s'arrêter... | |
|
| |
Dundas Invité
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 Dim 13 Mar 2005 - 14:40 | |
| out2 |
|
| |
Contenu sponsorisé
| Sujet: Re: Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 | |
| |
|
| |
| Duel: Marcel Bloch MB 152 vs. Curtiss P-36 | |
|